You've been reforging accessories wrong.

Menacing : r/Terraria

menacing master ninja gear terraria｜TikTok Search

Terraria Eye of Cthulhu Large Wall Decal

Mobile - Shadow's list of current Mobile Terraria Bugs

tfw you have reforge all of your accessories from lucky to menacing because *too* much luck is a concept that apparently exists : r/Terraria

Modifiers - Terraria Wiki

Terraria 1.4.5 update brings boulder rain, yes you read that right

Game Jolt - Share your creations

Menacing Tiki Mask..? : r/Terraria

menacing haunted chest - Skymods