Is Toradora a well-written version of Scum's wish?

Toradora has set a standard in romance anime. Similar to its story, Scum's wish can be considered a mirrored product. Who does their story better?

What is your impression/thought about the anime Kuzu no Honkai (scum's wish) so far? - Quora

The Art of Tiger Training or How to Become a Dragon – A Toradora! Review

What is your impression/thought about the anime Kuzu no Honkai (scum's wish) so far? - Quora

Review for Scum's Wish Collection

What inspired the anime 'Toradora'? - Quora

Rewatch][Spoilers]Kuzu no Honkai(Scum's Wish) Episode 2 Discussion : r/anime

Is Toradora a well-written version of Scum's wish?

Toradora! (Light Novel) Vol. 9 by Yuyuko Takemiya, Paperback

We're dating. Butwe're each other's replacements for someone else. (Scum's Wish) : r/anime

Is Toradora a well-written version of Scum's wish?